Our Menu
Our Kitchen Closes One Hour Before Closing. Delivery For Items On This Menu Is Available Through DoorDash. All of Our Employees Have Their Temperature Checked Before Entering the Building, Wear Masks, and Wash + Sanitize Their Hands Between Servicing Different Guests
Snacks + Appetizers
Mini Beef Wellington
$15.00
filet / puff pastry / mushroom duxelles / coleman's mustard
Loaded English Chips
$12.00
thick cut fries / grilled chicken / cheddar melted to order / amish bacon / green onions / ranch
Cauliflower and Cheese Dip
$12.00
cauliflower / onion / mushrooms / english cheddar / ciabatta / apple slices
Million Dollar Deviled Egg
$2.50/topped with kosher pickle
$3.00/topped with bacon
amish farm egg / tabasco / pickles / mustard
Fried Winter Vegetables
$8.00
ras el hanout / smoked chili ketchup
Philly Cheesesteak Spring Rolls
$13.00
dry aged ground beef / cheddar cheese / chipotle ketchup
Fresh House Made Pork Rinds
$6.00
ras el hanout spiced / buffalo dipping sauce
48 Hour Wings
$11.00/8pcs
choice of: house made ny buffalo, our own ky bbq, garlic parmesan or old bay
Soups and Salads
Tomato Soup
$8.00
tomatoes / cream / basil / house made croutons / parmesan
English Garden Salad
$15.00
amish mixed greens / cucumber / tomato / radish / spring onion / mint / cilantro / maldon sea salt / lemon juice / olive oil
Picnic Cobb Salad
$15.00
little gem / blue cheese / local bacon / hard boiled egg / tomatoes / sliced apples
Little Gem Caesar Salad
$13.00
pecorino / creamy caesar dressing / garlic croutons
Protein Add Ons
$7.00/Grilled Chicken Breast
$10.00/Filet Steak
$10.00/Roasted Salmon
Available Dressings
balsamic, citrus vinaigrette, ranch, blue cheese, 1000 island, honey mustard, extra virgin olive oil and balsamic
Sandwiches
Mike's Breakfast Sandwich
$13.50
organic fried egg / taylor pork roll / cheddar / cholula aioli / brioche / fries
Local Dry Aged Burger
$15.00
caramelized onions / lettuce / tomato / hp sauce / brioche / fries
Classic Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich
$25.00
old bay mayo / tomato / citrus slaw / brioche / fries
All Natural Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$13.50
old bay remoulade / citrus slaw / tomato / brioche / fries
Ploughman's Club Sandwich
$13.50
turkey / ham / muenster cheese / apple piccalilli / mustard aioli / lettuce / ciabatta / fries
New and Improved Cubano
$14.00
virginia ham / pork roll / bacon / whole grain mustard aioli / pepperoncini / muenster / fries
Sandwich/Burger Add Ons
$1.00/cheese
$2.00/buffalo sauce and blue cheese for chicken sandwich
$2.00/amish bacon
Pub Grub
Chicken Pot Pie
$16.00
all natural chicken / carrots / mushrooms / onion / potatoes / herb cream / puff pastry / garden salad
Veggie Pot Pie
$14.00
wild mushrooms / carrots / onion / potatoes / herb cream / puff pastry / garden salad
Fish and Chips
$18.00
cod loins / thick hand cut fries / tartar sauce / citrus slaw
Vegan Fish and Chips
$18.00
soy and pea fish filets / thick hand cut fries / vegan tartar sauce / citrus slaw
Bangers and Mash
$15.00
logan farms pork ale sausage / mushroom and onion gravy / garlic mash
Veggie Bangers and Mash
$18.00
vegetarian meatballs / mushroom and onion gravy / garlic mash
Joyce Farms Chicken Parmesan
$18.00
roasted garlic marinara / muenster / basil / baked ziti (optional: make it into a sandwich with a brioche bun)
Eggplant Parmesan
$16.00
roasted garlic marinara / muenster / basil / baked ziti (optional: make it into a sandwich with a brioche bun)
Roasted King Salmon
$18.00
king salmon / roasted shallots / honey-balsamic reduction / black bean and feta salad
Tikka Masala
$17.00
roasted chicken / tomato / onion / cream / curry spices / basmati rice
Vegetarian Tikka Masala
$14.00
tomato / mushrooms / onion / cream / curry spices / basmati rice
Mini Wellington Dinner
$23.50
filet / mushroom duxelles / puff pastry / mashed potatoes / garden salad
Baked Ziti
$17.00
italian sausage / ricotta / house made marinara / pecorino
Veggie Meatball Baked Ziti
$19.00
vegetarian sausage / ricotta / house made marinara / pecorino
Sides
English Chips (aka fries)
$3.50
old bay seasoning, beer battered
Citrus Slaw
$3.50
cabbage / carrots / red onion / extra virgin olive oil / lemon
Tomato Soup
$4.00
tomatoes / cream / basil / house made croutons / parmesan
Mashed Potatoes
$4.00
$4.50/with gravy
kennebec potatoes / cream / butter / garlic / coleman's mustard
Cauliflower and Cheese
$4.50
cauliflower / cream / white cheddar / blue shropshire cheese / nutmeg
Black Bean and Feta Salad
$4.00
lime / cilantro / tomato / cucumber / red onion / cumin / feta
Garden Salad
$4.50
amish mixed greens / tomatoes / cucumbers / local radishes / fresh mint and cilantro / extra virgin olive oil / lemon juice / other choices of dressing: blue cheese, ranch, balsamic, honey mustard
Basmati Rice
$3.50
olive oil / maldon salt / fresh herbs
Baked Ziti
$6.00
ziti / ricotta / house made marinara / pecorino
Desserts
Banoffee Pie
$8.00
graham cracker crust / bananas / toffee pudding / fresh whipped cream / belgian chocolate shavings
Fresh Apple Pie
$8.00
local apples / cinnamon / sugar / puff pastry / brown butter caramel crust
Kids
Fish and Chips
$9.00
cod loins / hand cut fries / tartar sauce
All Natural Chicken Strips
$9.50
grilled or fried joyce farms chicken / hand cut fries
Turkey and Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
roasted, sliced turkey breast / cheese / brioche burger bun
Cheesy Bacon Salad
$5.00
$12.00/with chicken
amish mixed greens / tomatoes / amish bacon / cheddar cheese
Baked Ziti
$6.00
$11.00/with sausage
$13.00/with chicken
ziti / ricotta / pecorino / optional marinara
Ready to Bake and/or Assemble (Please Allow for a Minimum 24 Hour Notice So We Can Curate Personalized Instructions on How to Finish Preparing All of Your Items)
Appetizers at Home
Accompanied with clear directions on how to cook and reheat. All our appetizers can be refrigerated for up to 5 days before being prepared.
Million Dollar Bacon Deviled Egg Platter
$12.00/for 4 eggs
$22.00/for 8 eggs
$43.00/for 16 eggs
Amish Farm Eggs, Seasoned with Tabasco, Kosher Pickle and Coleman's Mustard / Topped with Amish Bacon
Million Dollar Kosher Deviled Egg Platter
$10.00/for 4 eggs
$18.00/for 8 eggs
$35.00/for 16 eggs
Amish Farm Eggs, Seasoned with Tabasco, Kosher Pickle and Coleman's Mustard / Topped with Kosher Pickle
Jumbo Lump Mini Crab Cake Platter
$24.00/for 5 1oz cakes
$45.00/for 10 1oz cakes
$88.00/for 20 1oz cakes
100% Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes Seasoned with Lemon, Parsley and Old Bay / Accompanied By Our House Made Tartar Sauce
Baked Maryland Crab Dip
$24.00/for 8oz dip
$45.00/for 16oz dip
$88.00/for 32oz dip
Warm Dip with Maryland Crab, Caramelized Onion, a Blend of Three Creamy Cheeses and a Hint of Spice / Accompanied By Ciabatta Bread and Garlic Butter for Toasting
Mini Beef Wellington Platter
$30.00/for 4 pieces
$57.00/for 8 pieces
$115.00/for 16 pieces
2.5oz Filet Mignon Topped with Mushroom and White Wine Duxelles and Wrapped in Flaky Puff Pastry / Accompanied By Our House Made Coleman's Mustard
Philly Cheesesteak Spring Roll Platter
$13.00/for 5 spring rolls
$24.00/for 10 spring rolls
$47.00/for 20 spring rolls
Dry Aged Ground Beef With Cheddar Cheese and Dried Ancho Chili Ketchup, Wrapped in a Crispy Spring Roll Wrapper / Accompanied by Additional Ancho Chile Ketchup for Dipping
Tomato Basil Soup
$8.00/for 16 oz
$16.00/for 32 oz
Tomatoes / Cream / Fresh Basil / House Made Vegetable Stock / House Croutons and Pecorino Cheese Provided for Garnish
Garden Salad
$4.50/for 1 side salad
$16.00/for 4 side salads
Amish Mixed Greens / Cherry Tomatoes / English Cucumber / Local Radishes / Fresh Herbs / Choice of Dressing (ranch, house made blue cheese, honey mustard, or our signature balsamic)
Entrees at Home
Accompanied with clear directions on how to finish in the oven in under 30 minutes. All our meals can be refrigerated for up to 5 days before being prepared.
Wellington's Evening By The Fire
$23.50
5oz Filet Mignon, Topped with Mushroom and White Wine Duxelles and Wrapped in Flaky Puff Pastry / Roasted Brown Butter, Lemon Garlic + Parmesan Green Beans / Garden Salad with Amish Greens, Tomatoes, Winter Radish, Fresh Herbs, Green Onion and English Cucumber (pairing suggestion: bottle of Federalist cabernet sauvignon or Brendan's Preservation, a butter washed whiskey mule)
Chesapeake Bay Captain's Mooring
$25.00
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake / Roasted Brown Butter, Lemon Garlic + Parmesan Green Beans / Garden Salad with Amish Greens, Tomatoes, Winter Radish, Fresh Herbs, Green Onion and English Cucumber (pairing suggestion: bottle of Martin Codax albarino, Allagash White witbier or Rich's Off Shore Account, a modern mai tai)
Fisherman's Night In
$18.00
6oz Lemon and Herb King Salmon / Roasted Brown Butter, Lemon Garlic + Parmesan Green Beans (pairing suggested: bottle of Martin Codax albarino or Pimms Cup Cocktail)
Baker's Chicken Pot Pie At Home
$16.00
House Roasted Chicken Breast, Potatoes, Carrots, Mushrooms and Onion Baked Under Puff Pastry / Garden Salad with Amish greens, tomatoes, winter radish, fresh herbs, green onion and English cucumber (pairing suggestion: Old Speckled Hen (english pale ale) or bottle of Mimi chardonnay)
Baker's Veggie Pot Pie At Home
$14.00
Wild Mushrooms, Potatoes, Carrots, Onion and Herbs Baked Under Puff Pastry / Garden Salad with Amish Greens, Tomatoes, Winter Radish, Fresh Herbs, Green Onion and English Cucumber (pairing suggestion: Old Speckled Hen (english pale ale) or bottle of Mimi chardonnay)
Cheesemonger's Staycation Chicken Parmesan
$18.00
Breaded Chicken Breast with Marinara and Pecorino Romano Cheese / Ricotta Baked Ziti (pairing suggestion: bottle of Storypoint pinot noir or Carlsberg light lager)
Cheesemonger's Staycation Eggplant Parmesan
$16.00
Breaded Eggplant with Marinara and Pecorino Romano Cheese / Ricotta Baked Ziti (pairing suggestion: bottle of Storypoint pinot noir or Carlsberg light lager)
Sides at Home
Accompanied with clear directions on how to reheat in the oven, stove or assemble in under 15 minutes. All our sides can be refrigerated for up to 5 days before being prepared
Roasted Potato Wedges
$3.50/per portion
Beer Battered
Tomato Basil Soup
$8.00/for 16 oz
Tomatoes / Cream / Fresh Basil / House Made Vegetable Stock / House Croutons and Pecorino Cheese Provided for Garnish
Garden Salad
$4.50/per portion
Amish Mixed Greens / Cherry Tomatoes / English Cucumber / Local Radishes / Fresh Herbs / Choice of Dressing (ranch, house made blue cheese, honey mustard, or our signature balsamic)
Roasted Green Beans
$4.00/per portion
Lemon and Garlic Brown Butter / Parmesan
Garlic Bread
$4.00/per portion
Brioche / Fresh Garlic / Olive Oil
Baked Ziti
$6.00
Ricotta / Pecorino / Marinara Sauce
Citrus Slaw
$3.50/per portion
Cabbage / Carrots / Red Onion / Olive Oil / Lemon
Desserts at Home
Made In House
Banoffee Pie
$8.00/per slice
$45.00/whole pie (8 slices)
Graham Cracker Crust / Toffee Pudding / Bananas / Whipped Cream / Chocolate Shavings
Fresh Apple Pie
$8.00/per slice
$45.00/whole pie (8 slices)
Local Apples / Cinnamon / Sugar / Puff Pastry / Brown Butter Caramel Crust
Cocktails at Home
Never Pre-Batched!! All Alcohol Orders Must Be Accompanied By A Food Order. A Valid ID Must Be Presented Upon Delivery. Failure to Present Valid ID Will Legally Require Cancelation of Delivery and a Full Refund for Undelivered Liquor Items Within 24 Hours
Bloody Mary
$12.00/per serving
$40.00/for 4
Tomato Juice / Lemon / Lime / Worcestershire / Horseradish / Hot Sauce / Titos
John Green's Disguise (whiskey Pimm's Cup)
$15.00/per serving
$52.00/for 4
Quiet Man Irish Whiskey / Pimm's / Cucumber / Mint / Fresh Squeezed Lemon Juice / Ginger Beer - a man with many stories who tells no tales is priceless at any pub
Hidden Corner of 2nd Street (wintry pina colada)
$13.00/per serving
$44.00/for 4
Bacardi 4yr Aged Rum / Coconut Cream / Pineapple Juice / Strawberry / Eggnog Spice Blend - created by the owner in 2009 at this same location
Rich's Off Shore Account (modern mai tai)
$13.00/per serving
$44.00/for 4
Blend of Three Rums / Lime / Pineapple Juice / Orgeat / Cointreau / Angostura / Ginger Beer - an island concoction with vibes of being far from home
Mike the Hit Man (jalapeño margarita)
$14.00/per serving
$48.00/for 4
Cognac Cask Aged Diamante Tequila / Fresh Squeezed Lime Juice / Cointreau / Jalapeños - this drink may cause you to hit on others
Will's Wing Man (herbal gin mojito)
$15.00/per serving
$52.00/for 4
Plymouth Navy Gin / Creme Yvette / Fresh Lime Juice / Rosemary Tincture / Mint - a necessity at any COVID safe social gathering
Forbidden Union (irish whiskey old fashion)
$14.00/per serving
$48.00/for 4
Slane Irish Whiskey / Amaro / Bitters
Brendan's Preservation (wintry morning mule)
$15.00/per serving
$52.00/for 4
Butter Washed 100 Proof Evan Williams / Fresh Lemon Juice / Black Walnut Bitter / Blackberry Liqueur / Ginger Beer / Cinnamon
Cosmo
$5.00/per serving (with house vodka)
$11.00/per serving (with Ketel One + St. Germain)
Vodka / Orange Flavored Liqueur / Fresh Lime Juice / Dash of Cranberry
Beer and Wine at Home
Special Carry Out Prices. All Alcohol Orders Must Be Accompanied By Either By A Food Item. A Valid ID Must Be Presented Upon Delivery. Failure to Present Valid ID Will Legally Require Cancelation of Delivery and a Full Refund for Undelivered Liquor Items Within 24 Hours
Carlsberg
$5.00/can (16.9 oz cans)
$16.00/4pk
European Pale Lager - Copenhagen, DNK - the official beer of premier league, 5%
Old Speckled Hen
$7.00/bottle
$30.00/6pk
English Pale Ale - Morland, ENG - furity aromas with toffee and malt flavors, 5.2%
Newcastle Brown Ale
$5.00/bottle
$25.00/6pk
English Brown Ale - Newcastle, ENG - the UK'S "working man's" beer, 4.7%
Allagash White
$7.00/bottle
$30.00/6pk
Belgian Witbier - Portland, Maine - brewed with coriander and curacao orange peel, 5.1%
Figo Prosecco
$29.00/btl
Treviso, Italy: aromatic, fruity, bright sparkle
Mimi Chardonnay
$29.00/btl
Columbia River Valley, WA: elegant, soft, creamy depth
Eroica Riesling
$39.00/btl
Yakima Valley, WA: mouth watering acidity, lime, mandarin, subtle minerality
Martin Codax Albarino
$42.00/btl
Rias Baixas, Spain: crisp with notes of pear, passion fruit and apple
L'Escarelle Rose
$34.00/btl
Provence, France: bouquet of strawberries, white flowers and vanilla
Federalist Cabernet Sauvignon
$39.00/btl
California Cabernet: full bodied, notes of blackberry, cinnamon, spice
Storypoint Pinot Noir
$39.00/btl
Sonoma, CA: plush dar plum, blackberry, toasted oak
Delas Freres Cotes du Rhone
$39.00/btl
Rhone Valley, France: light bodied, berry notes, delicate tannins
Altos Ibericous Cranza Tempranillo
$36.00/btl
Rojia, Spain: floral, strawberry, raspberry, spicy, smoky notes, juicy tannins
Col Solare 2013
$120.00/btl
Specialty Non-Alcoholic Beverages at Home
English Tea and Honey Lemonade
$9.00/per drink
$32.00/for 4
Made to Order from Fresh Lemons and Our Signature English Tea Syrup
Strawberry Basil Lemonade
$7.00/per drink
$25.00/for 4
Made to Order from Fresh Lemons and Strawberry Basil Infused Syrup
Bloody Mary Mix
$16.00/32oz
Made to Order, in House and Based on a New York Family Recipe Dating Back Four Generations
Goslings Ginger Beer
$5.00/per can
$18.00/6pk
Red Bull
$6.00/per can
$14.00/four 8.4oz cans
House Made Condiments + Dressings
These Make Great Gifts for the Holidays
Mike Ellis' Chipotle Ketchup
$5.00/16oz
$8.00/8oz in gift mason jar
Delicious with Our Roasted Potatoes or in Place of That Boring Ketchup You Have in Your Fridge
The Alibi's Signature BBQ Sauce
$6.00/16oz
$9.00/8oz in gift mason jar
You Can Claim it as Your Own, We Wont Tell
House Made Balsamic Dressing
$7.00/16oz
$10.00/8oz in gift mason jar
Fresh Blue Cheese Dressing
$8.00/16oz
$11.00/8oz in gift mason jar
Made With Hard Cider
Old Bay Mayo
$7.00/16oz
$10.00/8oz gift mason jar
Great With Any Seafood
House Made Tartar Sauce
$7.00/16oz
$10.00/8oz gift mason jar
House Made Cocktail Sauce
$6.00/16oz
$9.00/8oz in gift mason jar
Fresh Bloody Mary Mix
$14.00/two 8oz gift mason jars
$16.00/32oz
Made to Order, in House and Based on a New York Family Recipe Dating Back Four Generations
Amish and Local Groceries for Your Home
Eggs
$5.00/dozen
Brown Farm Eggs
Bacon
$10.00/lb
Amish Farms, Lancaster PA
Chicken Breast
$7.00/each
Brined in House, Hormone Free and All Natural
Dry Aged Ground Beef
$7.00/lb
Veggie Meatballs
$2.00/each
Soy Based
Brioche Burger Bun
$1.25/each
Freshly Baked (contains eggs)
Sliced White Bread
$12.00/loaf
Sliced Loaf Baked Daily By Local, Lyon Bakery. Bread Orders Must Be Placed By 1pm Monday-Thursday to Guarantee Next Day Delivery. Orders Placed on Friday and Saturday May Not be Possible to Fill Until Monday
Sliced Whole Wheat
$12.00/loaf
Sliced Loaf Baked Daily By Local, Lyon Bakery. Bread Orders Must Be Placed By 1pm Monday-Thursday to Guarantee Next Day Delivery. Orders Placed on Friday and Saturday May Not be Possible to Fill Until Monday
Kids' Meals at Home
Accompanied with clear directions on how to reheat in the oven or assemble in under 15 minutes. All our kid's meals can be refrigerated for up to 5 days before being prepared
All Natural Chicken Strips
$9.50
Fried OR Grilled Local Chicken Breast / Baked Potato Wedges / Choice of Honey Mustard or Our House Made BBQ Sauce for Dipping
Baked Ziti
$6.00
$11.00/with sausage
$13.00/with chicken
Ziti with Sweet Butter, Ricotta + Pecorino Cheese with or without Fresh, House Made Marinara Sauce
Turkey or Ham and Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
Choice of Hormone Free Sliced Roasted Turkey Breast or Premium Pit Ham / Cheese / Brioche Burger Bun
Cheesy Bacon Salad
$5.00
$12.00/with chicken
Amish Mixed Greens / Tomatoes / Cheddar Cheese / Amish Bacon / Choice of Dressing (ranch, blue cheese, balsamic, or honey mustard)
Dog Food
Makes a Great Holiday Gift For Your Best Friend or The Dog Lover in Your Family
House Made Organic Dog Food
$7.00/lb
Our Dog Food is Made From Brown Rice, Hormone Free Chicken, Organic Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Kidney Beans and Fresh Ginger. That's It!!! Five Simple Ingredients! No Preservatives or Fillers, and Based on Recipes Designed by Veterinarians. Serve it to Your Best Friend as is, or Mix it with Their Normal Food for Added Nutrients
Zoom Party Kits + Holiday Gifts
Zoom Party Kits
Personalized Cocktail Design Service
Let us design a cocktail specifically designed to capture the spirit of your event, company or family. This service includes a in-depth and meaningful connection between the cocktail and your event, a detailed recipe, list of tools needed + tips and tricks for everyone from beginners to experts on how to make the cocktail. We will also curate cocktail kits for guests to pickup prior to your event, and in some cases, delivery can be arranged. Contact Rachel at rachel@thealibidc.com for details and pricing
Private Cocktail Class
The day of your event, one of our professional bartenders will join your Zoom event and walk through making your cocktail. This service also includes a Q + A opportunity following the class. Classes generally last 15-30 minutes
Appetizer, Entree and Dessert Pairings
Guests will have the opportunity to order appetizers, entrees and desserts from our "The Alibi at Home" menu. All of these items can designed to be prepared easily at home in your oven in under 30 minutes. These orders can be picked up with cocktail kits prior to the event, or in some cases, they can be delivered
Holiday Gifts
Packaged in Reusable Mason Jars with Cheeky Labels
Fresh Bloody Mary Mix
$14.00/two 8oz containers
Made in House and Based on a New York Family Recipe Dating Back Four Generations
Mike Ellis' Chipotle Ketchup
$8.00/8oz
A Delicious Replacement for That Boring Ketchup in Your Fridge
The Alibi's Signature BBQ Sauce
$9.00/8oz
You Can Claim it as Your Own, We Won't Tell
House Made Balsamic Dressing
$10.00/8oz
Fresh Blue Cheese Dressing
$11.00/8oz
Made With Hard Cider
Old Bay Mayo
$10.00/8oz
Great with Any Seafood
House Made Tartar Sauce
$10.00/8oz
Fresh Cocktail Sauce
$9.00/8oz
Banoffee Pie
$45.00
Graham Cracker Crust / Toffee Pudding / Bananas / Whipped Cream / Chocolate Shavings
Fresh Apple Pie
$45.00
Local Apples / Cinnamon / Sugar / Puff pastry / Brown Butter Caramel Crust
House Made Organic Dog Food
$7.00/lb
Made From Brown Rice, Hormone Free Chicken, Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Kidney beans and Fresh Ginger. No Preservatives, No Fillers and Based on Recipes Designed By Veterinarians.